Matches in Nanopublications for { ?s <https://w3id.org/linkflows/reviews/hasCommentText> ?o ?g. }
- comment hasCommentText "The object class should point to the link of the class: http://purl.org/np/RAiUYY1dbEDbcsscapEmbMMHsgJmjEJ1yUoNsxZIH1r90#transcription-of-stmn2, instead of the link to the nanopublication in which this class is published." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I believe the label in itself represents the meaning of the original article, but the qualifier wasn't the suitable one to express it. I have modified the qualifier from "generally" to "mostly" to specify that the original article claims that Shh is an essential regulator." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the feedback" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the feedback" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the feedback" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the feedback" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The original quote from the article has been replaced with a more specific one" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks, I updated the object class to http://purl.org/np/RAiUYY1dbEDbcsscapEmbMMHsgJmjEJ1yUoNsxZIH1r90#transcription-of-stmn2" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks, I updated the object slot to http://purl.org/np/RAiUYY1dbEDbcsscapEmbMMHsgJmjEJ1yUoNsxZIH1r90#transcription-of-stmn2" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks! m." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks! m." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Right - i see that adherence to the FAIR principles is a more specific form of adherence. the ontologist in me wants to make this a subclass :)" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the positive review on the class definition." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the positive review on the class definition." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the positive review on the class definition." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the positive review on the class definition." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thanks for the positive review on the class definition." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Indeed, I misunderstood the quote part. The quote now comes from (the abstract of) the original article" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I updated the quote, that now comes from the (abstract of the) original article." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I agree that this can be confusing. In response to a formalization review comment (3), I added a new class "Digital humanities research"which is a subclass of the resource "research" in wikidata and related to the resource "digital humanities" in wikidata." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I agree that this can be confusing. In response to a formalization review comment (3), I added a new class "Digital humanities research"which is a subclass of the resource "research" in wikidata and related to the resource "digital humanities" in wikidata." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Changed to the suggested doi. Thank you" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Provenance changed to show generated by a formalization activity." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Provenance was changed to show that it was generated by a formalization activity, and the necessary attributes of that template were added." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Suggestion adopted." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Whether we consider a protein in the context of a gene or the PRESENCE of the protein in that context is a subtle distinction whose need here eludes me. This requires further discussion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Added IRX3 and IRX5 as related classes" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "AND was changed to and" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no review needed, but was completed anyway" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no action needed" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no action needed" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no action needed" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no action needed" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Couldnt find the appropriate subclass for "regulatory element"" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "related classes added" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "An exact quote from the paper was added" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "An exact quote from the article was added" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The paper refers to both genes and both genes are regulated. Not sure if it should be split into two claims or remain as one" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "an exact quote from the article was added" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "the article link was updated as suggested" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "changed to the updated format where AND was replaced with and" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I agree that it was not clear that this is an instance. To address this review comment, I have created a new class (latest-release-of-openbiodiv), which is a subclass of software release (Q20631656) and related to openbiodiv-knowledge-graph, and I have updated the formalisation nanopub to say that 'The latest release of the OpenBiodiv knowledge graph contains semantic triples extracted from biodiversity literature'. Thank you for your review!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "We agree with this review comment and have addressed it by defining a new class license-with-non-commercial-clause which is a subclass of software license (Q79719) and is related to Q65071627 and have used this new class as the subject of our updated formalisation." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you! In response to your other review comment we made small changes to the formalisation." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for your review! While we agree that when it comes to legal issues a more concrete language should be used, our formalisation is of a statement which expresses an opinion rather than a legal fact. Licenses with a non-commercial clause do not inhibit reuse of biodiversity data because of legal reasons but as a consequence of the difficulty to reuse data." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for your review!" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I updated the class description to use skos:related to for glycocalyx" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "nothing to change" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "done" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "done" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no modification requested" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no modification requested" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "no modification requested" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "should be fixed hopefully. not sure as it's not clear how the problem appeared in the first place." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "should be fixed hopefully. not sure as it's not clear how the problem appeared in the first place." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I don't think the original publication shows a causal relationship. It seems to me only a correlation is proven." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The provenance of this nanopublication should be a FormalizationActivity and all the fields should be filled in in an appropriate manner: the link to the article, formalization author orcid, the exact quote from the article that contains the scientific claim." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The general structure of the formalization is good." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The qualifier should be "frequently" instead of "generally"." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The general class definition is good." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I would add a skos:related class with "metabolic abnormality" if such class exists." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "This issue has been resolved as indicated." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I have updated the class to refer to more appropriate wikidata class" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "addressed in previous comment" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Addressed in previous correction" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for your valuable suggestion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "This has been corrected." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for the suggestion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for the comment." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for your suggestion which has been implemented." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for your suggestion which has been implemented." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for the suggestion which was implemented." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Thank you for the suggestion which was implemented." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "We discussed that and agree to change the context (and the classes) so that "universal context" fits best." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Changed according to suggestion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Changed according to suggestion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Changed according to suggestion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Changed according to suggestion." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Chris Evelo added as author as agreed." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "Replaced by new class." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "The publication is about overlapping genes in the disease networks of CAKUT and in the vitamin A targets. There is no causality involved." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "No excess or deficiency involved here, that is just a statement that Vitamin A targets and CAKUT related proteins overlap (are sometimes the same)." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "We discussed that and agreed to "universal context" together with a change of subject and object classes." assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I agree" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "I agree" assertion.
- comment hasCommentText "added publication" assertion.